Jump to content

Newcastle - West Ham Player Ratings


lualualua
 Share

Recommended Posts

Given - 7 - Stabile. Unlucky too get punched in the balls by Butt.

 

Carr - 7 - Good comeback, good defensively and worked well with AOB

Ramage - 4 - Too slow, to stupid. His injury helped us massivly...

Huntington - 6 - Cant remeber too much of him, but atleast Ramage made him look like a superstar.

Solano - 8 - My MOM. He's so clever and really worked his peruvian balls off.

 

O'Brien - 7 - Great game. Fast, clever, linked well with Carr, and was good defensivly thanks too his pace.

Butt - 6 - Gave away some stupid free kicks but worked hard.

Parker - 7 - The real Parker is back. Threw himself at everything and worked really gard.

Milner - 8 - Very good game. Had tones of space and took advantage of it. Clever goal.

 

Dyer - 6 - Didnt do very much. Him and Oba are starting to understand eachother.

Martins - 6 - Very unlucky not to score. If it wasnt for Caroll, he would have put 2 or 3 away.

-----------------

Harper - 7 - Did well most of the time. Nice work stopping the one on one.

Edgar - 7 - Kept the WH strikers quiet and did his job MUCH better than Ramage.

Edited by lualualua
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 69
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Given - 7

 

Carr - 7

Ramage - 4

Huntington - 6

Solano - 9 :angry::blink:

 

O'Brien - 7

Butt - 6

Parker - 7

Milner - 8

 

Dyer - 6

Martins - 6

-----------------

Harper - 7

Edgar - 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Given - 7

 

Carr - 7

Ramage - 4

Huntington - 6

Solano - 9 :angry::blink:

 

O'Brien - 7

Butt - 6

Parker - 7

Milner - 8

 

Dyer - 6

Martins - 6

-----------------

Harper - 7

Edgar - 7

 

did u even watch the game?? he was the best player on the pitch

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Given - 7

 

Carr - 7

Ramage - 4

Huntington - 6

Solano - 9 :angry::blink:

 

O'Brien - 7

Butt - 6

Parker - 7

Milner - 8

 

Dyer - 6

Martins - 6

-----------------

Harper - 7

Edgar - 7

 

did u even watch the game?? he was the best player on the pitch

 

 

but a 9?

 

 

you don't think that's being a little too generous?

 

I mean sure he deserves praise for his performance... but a 9? they give Hat-trick heroes 10, Nobby was good by all accounts, but does he genuinely deserve a 9? :angry:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Given - 7

 

Carr - 7

Ramage - 4 **** One man disaster zone

Huntington - 6

Solano - 8

 

O'Brien - 7

Butt - 8

Parker - 6

Milner - 9 **** worked very hard (as usual)

 

Dyer - 3 **** disgraceful performance

Martins - 7

 

Harper - 7

Edgar - 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Shay - 8 - only let in 2 goals.

Solano - 10 - Great penalty from the best converted RB in world football.

Ramage - 7 - Only responsible for 1 goal this time, much improved.

Huntington - 7 - Just for the hair.

Carr - 8 - Didn't look as fat, welcome back.

Milner - 10 - Great goal, England call up a cert.

Butt - 10 - Best ginger defensive midfielder in the world.

Parker - 0 - To blame for everything this season, cost us all 3 points.

O'Brien - 10 - Best wing display in the history of the club.

Martins - 0 - Didn't score a long range rocket, must improve.

Dyer - 10 - No injuries.

 

Subs

 

Harper - 10 - Clean sheet.

Edgar - 8 - Will play for Canada one day if he keeps playing like that.

 

Roeder - 10 - 100% improvement over the Birmingham match, extend that contract Freddy.

 

Fans - 10 - Best in the universe tbh.

 

Century radio commentary - 6 - OK.

Edited by Howaythetoon
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Shay - 8 - only let in 2 goals.

Solano - 10 - Great penalty from the best converted RB in world football.

Ramage - 7 - Only responsible for 1 goal this time, much improved.

Huntington - 7 - Just for the hair.

Carr - 8 - Didn't look as fat, welcome back.

Milner - 10 - Great goal, England call up a cert.

Butt - 10 - Best ginger defensive midfielder in the world.

Parker - 0 - To blame for everything this season, cost us all 3 points.

O'Brien - 10 - Best wing display in the history of the club.

Martins - 0 - Didn't score a long range rocket, must improve.

Dyer - 10 - No injuries.

 

Subs

 

Harper - 10 - Clean sheet.

Edgar - 8 - Will play for Canada one day if he keeps playing like that.

 

Roeder - 10 - 100% improvement over the Birmingham match, extend that contract Freddy.

 

Fans - 10 - Best in the universe tbh.

 

Century radio commentary - 6 - OK.

 

 

Ratings- 11- Spinal Tap-Tastic ratings, best in the history of rating things

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Given - 7 - Stabile. Unlucky too get punched in the balls by Butt.

 

Carr - 7 - Good comeback, god defensively and worked well with AOB

Ramage - 4 - Too slow, to stupid. His injury helped us massivly...

Huntington - 6 - Cant remeber too much of him, but atleast Ramage made him look like a superstar.

Solano - 9 - My MOM. He's so clever and really worked his peruvian balls off.

 

O'Brien - 7 - Great game. Fast, clever, linked well with Carr, and was good defensivly thanks too his pace.

Butt - 6 - Gave away some stupid free kicks but worked hard.

Parker - 7 - The real Parker is back. Threw himself at everything and worked really gard.

Milner - 8 - Very good game. Had tones of space and took advantage of it. Clever goal.

 

Dyer - 6 - Didnt do very much. Him and Oba are starting to understand eachother.

Martins - 6 - Very unlucky not to score. If it wasnt for Caroll, he would have put 2 or 3 away.

-----------------

Harper - 7 - Did well most of the time. Nice work stopping the one on one.

Edgar - 7 - Kept the WH strikers quiet and did hid job MUCH better than Ramage.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Given - 7 - Stabile. Unlucky too get punched in the balls by Butt.

 

Carr - 7 - Good comeback, god defensively and worked well with AOB

Ramage - 4 - Too slow, to stupid. His injury helped us massivly...

Huntington - 6 - Cant remeber too much of him, but atleast Ramage made him look like a superstar.

Solano - 9 - My MOM. He's so clever and really worked his peruvian balls off.

 

O'Brien - 7 - Great game. Fast, clever, linked well with Carr, and was good defensivly thanks too his pace.

Butt - 6 - Gave away some stupid free kicks but worked hard.

Parker - 7 - The real Parker is back. Threw himself at everything and worked really gard.

Milner - 8 - Very good game. Had tones of space and took advantage of it. Clever goal.

 

Dyer - 6 - Didnt do very much. Him and Oba are starting to understand eachother.

Martins - 6 - Very unlucky not to score. If it wasnt for Caroll, he would have put 2 or 3 away.

-----------------

Harper - 7 - Did well most of the time. Nice work stopping the one on one.

Edgar - 7 - Kept the WH strikers quiet and did hid job MUCH better than Ramage.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Given - 7 - Stabile. Unlucky too get punched in the balls by Butt.

 

Carr - 7 - Good comeback, god defensively and worked well with AOB

Ramage - 4 - Too slow, to stupid. His injury helped us massivly...

Huntington - 6 - Cant remeber too much of him, but atleast Ramage made him look like a superstar.

Solano - 9 - My MOM. He's so clever and really worked his peruvian balls off.

 

O'Brien - 7 - Great game. Fast, clever, linked well with Carr, and was good defensivly thanks too his pace.

Butt - 6 - Gave away some stupid free kicks but worked hard.

Parker - 7 - The real Parker is back. Threw himself at everything and worked really gard.

Milner - 8 - Very good game. Had tones of space and took advantage of it. Clever goal.

 

Dyer - 6 - Didnt do very much. Him and Oba are starting to understand eachother.

Martins - 6 - Very unlucky not to score. If it wasnt for Caroll, he would have put 2 or 3 away.

-----------------

Harper - 7 - Did well most of the time. Nice work stopping the one on one.

Edgar - 7 - Kept the WH strikers quiet and did hid job MUCH better than Ramage.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Carr - 7 - Good comeback, god defensively and worked well with AOB

High praise indeed, also, we let Andy go to Pompey ages ago marra :blink:

 

Edgar - 7 - Kept the WH strikers quiet and did hid job MUCH better than Ramage.

personally I prefer our center halves not to play Hide and Seek midgame, mind :angry:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

wot game were you watching ? carr was abysmal couldn,tput two passes together every time he passed to another toon player there was somebody up his arse it was just get me out of jail ,useless wot did he give us today? ramage i hope he doesnt get back in should have won today ,but to come back from 2 goals down says a lot.get rid of roeder and mcdermott.clark and the rest of the hangers on bring in deuschamps somebody who has won things both as a player and a manager : :blink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

wot game were you watching ? carr was abysmal couldn,tput two passes together every time he passed to another toon player there was somebody up his arse it was just get me out of jail ,useless wot did he give us today? ramage i hope he doesnt get back in should have won today ,but to come back from 2 goals down says a lot.get rid of roeder and mcdermott.clark and the rest of the hangers on bring in deuschamps somebody who has won things both as a player and a manager : :angry:

:blink: God, that hurts my eyes....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Given 6 - fair peformence

 

Carr 5 - Horrible from the start,too many missed pass's

 

Ramage 3 - Harewood toyed with him,his injury was the best thing that happend to us today

 

Huntington 7 - Good Peformence was solid and won many balls in the air

 

Solano 7 - Looked good today,solid at the back and a threat upfront

 

Parker 6 - Wasn't at his best,Gave many freekicks to them.

 

Butt 7 - Good peformence,some nice touchs

 

Milner 7 - Scored an importent goal,in fantastic form recently

 

O'Brien 7 - Good use of his pace,Cross's seem better,wouldve had Luque over him but he was decent today

 

Dyer 6 - Didnt show alot,wasn't a threat the West Hams defence

 

Martins 7 - Tryed hard,should scored in the first half

 

Subs:

 

Harper 7 - Always a pleasure to see him play (Liverpool game aside), Good peformence and kept us in it with his good handling of the 1 on 1 situation

 

Edgar 7 - He did a fantastic job,shouldve started instead of ramage today

 

 

Overall 6 - A home draw against a relegation threatend side,points wasted as ever,and we got lucky finishing with a point

Link to comment
Share on other sites

wot game were you watching ? carr was abysmal couldn,tput two passes together every time he passed to another toon player there was somebody up his arse it was just get me out of jail ,useless wot did he give us today? ramage i hope he doesnt get back in should have won today ,but to come back from 2 goals down says a lot.get rid of roeder and mcdermott.clark and the rest of the hangers on bring in deuschamps somebody who has won things both as a player and a manager : :angry:

 

Like watching Steven Carr trying to type.. :blink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Carr - 7 - Good comeback, god defensively and worked well with AOB

High praise indeed, also, we let Andy go to Pompey ages ago marra :angry:

 

Edgar - 7 - Kept the WH strikers quiet and did hid job MUCH better than Ramage.

personally I prefer our center halves not to play Hide and Seek midgame, mind :angry:

 

happy now? u are one tough customer :blink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Carr - 7 - Good comeback, god defensively and worked well with AOB

High praise indeed, also, we let Andy go to Pompey ages ago marra :angry:

 

Edgar - 7 - Kept the WH strikers quiet and did hid job MUCH better than Ramage.

personally I prefer our center halves not to play Hide and Seek midgame, mind :(

 

happy now? u are one tough customer :blink:

happy now... what?

 

Nothing's changed :angry:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bloody hell Fush, you must be bored! Quarreling with people about ratings for a game you haven't even seen!

 

 

:blink:

 

who me? Bored? ya think?

 

Jealous more's to the point, miss watching football up close and personal. Stuill I can feel better by mocking and ridiculing grammar and excessively biased commentary.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought Solano was poor today, penalty excepted. :blink:

 

He started anythign decent we did with the ball, when Given finally realised passing it to Nobby is better than humping it up to our small strikeforce.

 

He was also the only defender who was doing any sort of job at the back early on when we gave them goals and was stopping their attacks with well timed cynical fouls instead of everyone elses method of letting players roll past you or just not marking them! And he was one of the few at the back who seemed to be helping others by actually talking to them, because our team must'nt be speaking to each other the way they leave each other exposed by never giving anyone a shoit!

 

Thought we looked better at the back when Edgar came on than we had been before.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.