BLACKANDWHITEGEORDIE

Why would him wanting his own staff be a problem. That is a norm when new Head Coaches start. Do we really need any of the dross we have?

Sunday Mirror reporting that Carver will not be considered for the job.

Jonas was on 60 grand a week. At what level do you pay him if he is not going to be a first team regular and would he accept it. I would have kept him on in a coaching capacity (dependent on him getting his badges).

Because those named are not regular first team players, so what difference would it make.

If Charnley does appoint Carver and everything goes pear shaped pretty quickly, Ashley will sack Charnley in less time than it takes him to say 'You're fired'.

If they have to re-run the next World Cup venue, both Russia and Qatar will bankrupt FIFA.

The money is based on the number of times Sky show Newcastle games. Outside the top 4, Sky Sports rate Newcastle highly because of the number of viewers they attract in the UK.

If the new coach told Charnley that getting shot of the coaching staff was a deal breaker then they would all leave and he would bring in his own people, contracts or not. After 5 minutes of fame how receptive do you believe Carver would be to being a No. 2 again and the new coach would know that he was a poisoned chalice.

Dier only played so many games because of Walker's injuries. If MU had better offers for Chicarito, why did he only go out on loan. If you were Redmond would you rather play in front of 50000 every other week or 20 odd thousand with Norwich, especially as they would be one of the favourites to go straight back down. Players leave clubs for different reasons. What is wrong with a loan player from Chelsea?

Keegan or Shearer don't get out of bed for less than £2 million.

Whoever gets the job needs to be ruthless in clearing out the dross once and for all. Outs by their own choice: Krul, Tiote, Cisse, Sissoko Outs by club: Elliot, Williamson, Raylor, Saylor, Dummett, Anita, Obertan, Gouffran, Ameobi, Riviere Ins: Dier, Redmond, Bolasie, Austin, Van Aanholt, Adrian, Bamford, Dembele, Guidetti, Chicarito, Vlaar, Van Diijk

Do you seriously believes Ashley needs any more PR. He is the best known club owner in the EPL maybe for all the wrong reasons but self made billionaires like him don't give a s**t whether it is good or bad.

Anyone who watched Sky Sports prior to the match would have been aware of Ashley's interview.

Whoever gets the job needs to implement a major clear out including Carver, Stone, Woodman, Beardsley, and a major shake up in the medical staff as his first priority. After being in charge for 9 games Carver would be a nightmare if he was demoted.

JFH being quoted in the Sun as next Head Coach.

The least Ashley can do for Jonas is give him a one year rolling contract on reduced terms. Jonas saved Ashley millions yesterday. I would go further and get him to take his coaching badges and then start by looking after the kids. Our one and only player who could inspire them.

The way you talk you would think that pre Ashley we were regular winners of the CL and FA Cup. Do you actually go to SJP or just another armchair critic.

The sign of that you have good coaches is that the bigger clubs soon snap them up. Not one of ours from Carver upwards has ever been approached. Probably the last really good player to come through was Gazza and the likes of Waddle and Alan Suddick. Our current crop are absolutely diabolical and I have doubts whether they could get jobs in the Conference League. Bearing in mind that one of Ashley's prime motivators is to buy cheap ands sell expensive you would think he would get the best coaches available and scouts who specialise in the under 18's footballers.

If Ashley had spent £500000 on a short term contract for Dick Advocaat would we be in the position we are now?

If 12 years is the max how come Gerrard lasted 17 years playing in the PL. That probably works out at an extra £50 million.

Not sure why De Gea came off on Sunday. The club have been very quiet on the reason. But he walked off and took part in the after match pitch celebrations. That could mean that Valdes will be in goal and that could be MU's thank you to Steve Bruce for his past services.

I would agree top actors and musicians earn a lot more than footballers but the profits they produce for the film and record companies is much higher than say what Rooney generates at OId Trafford.

Ashley has been there and bought the t shirt (not sure what size) so what reasons would he have for selling. His public profile has never been so high (for all the wrong reasons) the more sales SD (his real love) generate the higher will go his profits and his personal fortune.

Steve Bruce has already started the mind games by stating in the Sunday press that 'Manchester United owe me big time'.

Football is a rarity in business where in general you get the same money whether you win, draw or lose. Where a goalkeeper gets nearly a third of what the centre half gets and nearly half of what the midfielder gets. The players involved being Krul, Colo and Jonas.