TOPTOON

Yeah, we tried that, remember? Besides, Milner doesn't deserve to lose his place. On current form, he's our best winger. Last time we tried it was in that Uefa game and Duff was on fire, it worked imo, i don't know why he didn't stick with it. I like Milner but i don't think he's quite as good as Duff and Zoggy, just my opinion. We tried it a few other times too, and it just didn't work. No we didn't. When?.. Zoggy's hardly played with Duff.... we should have though imo Duff was MOM the last time he played there, crap opposition like i know but still he loked at home on the right.

Yeah, we tried that, remember? Besides, Milner doesn't deserve to lose his place. On current form, he's our best winger. Last time we tried it was in that Uefa game and Duff was on fire, it worked imo, i don't know why he didn't stick with it. I like Milner but i don't think he's quite as good as Duff and Zoggy, just my opinion.

Zoggy and duff are no LB's . They'd be wasted there too. They are our best Wingers man! Stick Duff RW and Zoggy on the left. If anyone has to be played out of position its unfortunatly (for him and us) Ramage, he's not great there but with bernard stryggling with fitness and Baba out its the best we can do for now. Zoggy's going to have to come back more to help out if/when we are against it.

Unfortunately think you're going to be right Gemmill

About time too! Parkers class! Hope he doesn't get injured ffs

As we rested Shola against Tallin i wouldn't be surprised to see him start, however i'd be very tempted to go 4411 on this one as if we lose out in midfield we are going even more screwed. Time to be sensible and accept that if we go out with our best in a 442 we are still going to get beat. This way we can frustrate them and maybe nick something. -----------Harper Car---Taylor---Moore---Ramage* Duff---Parker---Butt---Zoggy ------------------Emre ----------Martins Subs **** Krul Bernard* If Bernard is fit and looking sharper it maybe time to throw him in. Milner Sibierski Ameobi

I like taylor Ramage and Moore as center backs, Bramble should be history now he's blown his chances time and time again and is a complete liability costing us points and unsettling the whole team (he can't do confidence any good). Tough to pick the two center backs out of taylor ramage and Moore. as taylor looked great there last night but Ramage and Moore have always looked decent to me when deployed in there propper CB positions. Car although not great hasn't been as bad as i feared.......... SO FAR!! Very tough choice really for Man U, i think i'd go: Car Taylor Moore Ramage* *Unless Bernard is doing particularly well in training, then stick him in and put Ramage on the bench. If Car takes turn for the worst and i do expect him to within the next few games then maybe Ramage taylor or possibly even Milner at RB. It'd also be very interesting to see how a taylor ramage CB partnership would go when/if Bernard gets fit or when Baba eventually comes back. Inexperienced i know but it could work well imo!

The sooner Bramble is out of st James's the better i've never known one player to cost us so many points through individual howlers, PLUS he does the entire confidence of the team no good at all so he does alot more damage than most people realize. Hopefully take Luque with him too!

We obviously want to win, but i'd also use this as a chance for Martins to boost his confidence (i.e. score) and if now fit to ease Taylor and Sibeiski back into the action. Also to Give Duff more rest and possibly Parker too (god forbid he gets injured), depending on Butt's current attitude. Harper Taylor Ramage Moore Baba (if fit, if not bernard?) Milner Butt Emre Zoggy Martins Sibeiski Subs Krul Huntingdon Car Pattison (give the lad a run out if weare cruising) Bernard? (if fit) Parker (just in case) O'brien (give the lad a run out if we are cruising) Bramble and Luque should be cast out !!!

We just need to give Shambles away now he's terrible!!

This is a serious poll ! So howcome you've got a Baba option? and a rossi? Baba and a Rossi are options for the misguided few, Bramble is not an option because that is beyond the realmes of misguided

This is a serious poll !

I'm going Parker too. You know he'll always give 100% to our cause and the guy is a real grafter who does his job so so well. Given is probably the best shot stopper i've ever seen, but hoofs it too much for my liking (although how much he is instructed to and having the likes of Boumsong, Bramble and o'brien around maybe h's not that much to blame). Emre and Zoggy i also like alot as they posess geniune class and skill!

Who's our best player? Discuss.

Oh Shit!! How the fuck do you alter the poll?? I can't seem to change it! Oh Bollocks! Administrator help please!!!!

If crouch plays then should we play taylor at RB ? No doubts we have a small team i've heard the smallest in the prem, If crouch Plays tomorrow we should imo play Taylor at RB or we could get really punished from set plays and crosses. He'd probably (almost certainly) do a better Job than Car anyhow defensively who is a weak link. car as it happens hasn't been quite as bad as i thought he'd be so far, but Taylor for me being the tallest defender (at 6'2) we have, should definately play if fit to try and nullify that lanky streak of piss crouch!

Appently his comeback is two weeks away

Sorry i must have missed that Rossi restriction. Bloody daft imo as Man u may eventually want to play him in Europe too! Good experience for the lad. Ameobi sounds 50/50 for the game so if he doesn't make it either straight swap for The Sib (which i think i'd do) or go with Parker and butt in the center and play Emre or perhaps Zoggy in the hole behind Martins. Think its too big a gamble to shove Rossi in just yet.

Harper was a very good keeper and it was touch and go whether to opt for him or Shay as no 1. Shay threatened to walk so they gave him no. 1 spot and Harps has been unlucky that Shay's fitness record (and form for that matter) has been nothing short of incredible ever since. The odd occasion Harps has come on he's looked understandably rusty in the past, but in all fairness looked fine so far this season, time will tell!

Good player when fit, but a perma crock so best to just not make any plans with him, hope he gets fit but have heard he is on the brink of a come back for so long its boring now.

Be interesting to see if Martins could operate as a lone striker if needs be. Personally i'd preffer two but the need may arise i.e. Chelski away

Shit! Begs the question why he didn't have the operation at the end of last season giving him a hell of alot of time to recover. Him and martins seem to be a decent front two, i suppose now its alternate Ameobi and the Sib with Martins untill Xmas and then try and get another 'Big Man' in while Shola recovers or try Martins up front on his own which may not work. Hows Baptista doing at Arsenal?

Big baba fan i see! When did we have two Milners? Imo Sibierski has to be at least on the bench as shola's fitness is very iffy and not sure Bernard's fitness is up to scratch yet.

I really rate Zoggy, think he's a cracking player but Emre and parker have to start against Liverpool, the team should be unchanged injuries allowing (harper in for Given by the looks). Emre's a special little player very intellegent great vision and passing ability and also gets really stuck in too, good with a dead ball and has a very good shot too, i don't understand his critics at all as we have been missing a central midfield playmaker of his class for some time! zoggy's very unlucky that we managed to get Duff and i would certainly look to use him from the bench come wednesday for anyone who is struggling.

Injuries allowing got to be the same for me, except Harper in for the injured Given. Subs bench on Sunday we had: HARPER BUTT ZOGGY (should be in the team but can't drop anyone after Sunday, bring him on at some point though) ROSSI THE SIB (Looking quite good imo if Shola's struggling bring him on) On Wednesday i'm thinking Krul on the bench for Harper and Taylor should be on there too for Rossi imo! Rossi should be played in our next UEFA game (at least 45 mins).